Friday, August 28, 2009

Application Of Islamic Law In The Middle East

However, banks and European contractors intending to enter into contracts whether for financing or constructing projects in the Middle East are strongly advised to ask a question of law and seek legal advice on the validity of certain contract provisions, and especially with regard to charging interest.

With this in mind, we will present in part two of this article a brief survey and the public about the level of implementation of Islamic law in several countries of the Arab Middle East, showing where and how far Islamic law applies.

Associated with the same problem and a separate article we deal with the concept and the prohibition of interest under Islamic law as well as a brief outline of Islamic banking, refers to a model contract used in financing construction and other projects.

Prior to that, and relate to their subject matter, a sense of Islamic law and Islamic brief background may be useful to introduce the reader to some of the terminology used by Islamic jurists. Also, we should try to remove the misunderstanding that exists between some European jurists and businessmen that there is a law of a single Arab or Middle Eastern. Instead, we will refer to the common features of the Arab Middle East Middle East and Arab law.

The concept of Islam and Sharia Law

Islam as a religion revealed to the Prophet Mohammed first in the year 610 in Mecca, Saudi Arabia. According to Islamic belief in Muhammad as a messenger sent by the "Ala" to complete the messages of previous prophets such as Moses and Jesus. "ALA" is the Arabic word for God, and faith of Islam is based on the unity of God, with one and the same God for Muslims, Christians and Jews.

This scripture Moro is "Quran", which was revealed to Prophet Muhammad and put the code of ethics and rules for people to follow.

According to the Quran, all the prophets are the ones blessed with divine revelation and sent by God to teach the kind of people. Quran recognizes Christians and Jews as a revelation from God, and calls for peaceful coexistence and dialogue with Jews and Christians (see Al-Quran, Surah 2 / 135 and 16/125 Letter). Surah 2 / 190 which states "and fight in the way of God those who fight you, but do not limit the sin, God does not like aggressors / exceeded the limit". Therefore, a legitimate war of self defense, and killing of innocent civilians is a crime and aggression that the Koran prohibited.

Al-Quran is the primary and first source of Islamic law, or so-called "Sharia" in Arabic. For Muslims, the Quran has laid down provisions covering the entire way of life. This rule is both a binding and obligatory nature or recommended or advisable or forbidden and rejected.

The second source of Sharia is the "Hadith" is saying and act as reported from the Prophet Muhammad. Thus, Islamic law or Sharia is the body of rules and laws derived from the Quran and Hadith primary. Islamic Sharia law is developed and the interpretation, elaboration and study the Koran and Hadith.

There are five main schools of Islamic law:

The four major Sunni schools as Hanafi, Maliki, and Hanbali schools Shaffi.

In addition to Sunni schools, there is a large Shiat Jafari school, founded by Ja'far al-Sadiq, the grandson of the Prophet Muhammad. Shiites make the most of the Muslims in Iraq and Iran.

All schools of Islamic law depends on the text of the Quran and Hadith. The main difference between them comes from different interpretations of the text of the Quran and Hadith, and from secondary sources they use to solve the problems of religion and law.

Middle Eastern Law, or Law

As said before, there is no uniform law of the Middle East or Arab, or have one uniform legal system for all Arab countries, although most Arab countries adopted the codified civil law system, based on the Egyptian civil code, as opposed to the system English common law.

During the Ottoman Empire before the First World War, the Ottoman government preparing Hanafi law in a consistent Civil Code called "Majella", which applied to the Arab countries, which is part of the Ottoman Empire. Majella is consistently applied in the Arab countries after the fall of the Ottoman Empire, until every Arab country from its own legal system and enacted the Civil Code.

With the partition of the Ottoman Empire, France and Britain have been taken in other Arab countries. Under the colonial policy of the West, particularly the influence of Western legal system codified French law and French Civil Code grows in Arab countries, and the legislative process to reconcile between Islamic and Western legal began1 slowly. As a result, direct application of Islamic law continued to decline.

Egyptian Civil Code of 1948 is the first and successful product of the process. Egyptian Civil Code author, Dr. Sanhuri, managed to reconcile and bring together in harmony with Shariah principles and provisions of the European Civil Code and in particular the French Civil Code.

Now all Arab countries except Saudi Arabia and Oman modern civil code based wholly or partly in the Egyptian Civil Code. Thus, one common feature among the Arab countries the law is parity or even parity provisions of the Civil Code. Another common feature is the main application of Islamic law in all Arab countries are directly or indirectly, as described later.

As understood from the introduction above, there is no single law of Arab or Middle Eastern or uniform, but the law in Arab countries together share many common features and similarities, which makes comparative view of law that an item of interest to lawyers.

In addition to the application of Sharia, the influence of Majella and the uniformity of the source of Arab civil code as mentioned previously, there are other common factors such as the stacking of judges and lawyers among the Arab countries, common history and common language, which all together with common law and legal strategies between Arab countries.

Application of Islamic Law

There is no single rule of when and where to apply Sharia application varies from one country to another and depend on religion and social structure of society, the legal system, and the provisions of the constitution and civil code of each Arab country.

Sharia may apply either directly as a common law country, which has not been fully developed system of codified law, or by the application of laws based on total or in part in Islamic law, or as a source of law to fill the legal vacuum when certain laws without the necessary provisions.

In Saudi Arabia, where there are no Civil Law, Sharia operates and applies directly as state common law, both the commercial courts and courts personal belongings. No other law applies if contrary to the Sharia. For traders who concluded such contracts with Saudi companies, including provisions for interest, or for groups of banks that provide syndicated loans to clients Arabia, it is definitely advisable to see whether the terms of their contracts are valid or enforceable under Islamic law. Parties should take the prohibition of interest under Sharia into account when negotiating the settlement. Even excessive penalty clauses in a contract may be held unenforceable by a Saudi court, based on the general principles of Sharia. However, direct application of Sharia was limited to Saudi Arabia in the fields of law, where the law does not exist. Although Sharia is a common law country, Saudi Arabia has imposed a large amount of legislation, the so-called "regulation" encompasses various areas of law including Corporate Law, Code of Commerce and the Law of the tender.

In other Arab countries which adopted the civil code and civil law system, Sharia plays a lesser role and applies particularly in areas such as family law, marriage and inheritance.

In this country, family law has been established based on one or more Islamic schools identified earlier, while commercial and civil codes are based in Europe and to some extent on Islamic law.

In the said countries where a comprehensive legal system of civil law is established, the rule of Sharia, or the application of other things than the family law also varies depending on the constitutional provisions of the Law and Civil Code countries.

Constitution of the Arab countries including Egypt, Syria, Kuwait, Bahrain, Qatar, UAE and Yemen Sharia refers to both as: the main source of law or legal sources. Consequently, and in cases where Lacuna law without legislative provisions, the principles of Sharia is to fill the gap either as the first source or as a source law2.

Where the constitution describes Sharia as a source of "The" primary law, the hierarchy means that all laws and statues must comply with Shariah principles. If you meet with is another question, as we shall see later.

The following is a brief survey of certain provisions of the constitution and civil code of some Arab countries have dealt with the application of Sharia.

Arab Constitutions:

Egypt:

Article 2 amended the constitution of Egypt, as amended in 1980, states that:

"The principles of Sharia are the main source of legislation in the Arab Republic of Egypt and ..."

The application of this article comes under test, when in 1985 the rector of Al Azhar to bring a case against the president and parliament of Egypt and others. Al-Azhar argues that the provisions of Civil Code Article 226 provides such interest 0f the Egyptian Civil Code is unconstitutional in view of Article 2 amended the Constitution, adopt Sharia as THE primary source of law.

The Court rejected this contention and decided that Article 2 does not have retroactive effect to make the existing law unconstitutional, but the court held that Article 2 imposed legislative obligation to carry all future legislation for these Sharia3.

Special Commission to prepare amendments to the Constitution in 1980 reported that the purpose of Article 2 of the Constitution are:

"In the parliamentary strength to seek help in the direction of Sharia, the exclusion of any other sources, to discover what he was looking for, then, if he did not find any explicit decision, he must use Sharia Resources interpretive effort (al-ijtihadiyya) to come to the right policy to follow and does not violate the basic and general principles of Sharia. "This principle is confirmed in the Decision of the constitutional court of Egypt 15. May 1993 there was no law in the future should be against the rules of formal Sharia.4

Kuwait:

Article 2 of the Constitution of Kuwait stated that:

"State religion is Islam and Islamic Sharia is the main source of law and."

It is mentioned that according to this article, Sharia is the source of the principles, and not a source of law.

In 1992, the Constitutional Court rejected the claim that Kuwait Kuwait Civil Code provides for the interest is unconstitutional and contrary to Article 2 of the Constitution. The Court noted that Article 2 of the Constitution is a political directive to legislators to use the provisions of Sharia as far as possible. Sharia is the source, not the only source and there is nothing to prevent the legislature applying from other sources, besides Sharia.5

UAE:

In the UAE it is quite obvious, because, while Article 7 of the Constitution UAE is the Sharia as the main source of law, Article 75 of the Law Union in 1973 the Supreme Court determined that the highest Supreme Court must first apply the Sharia and other applicable legal time in accordance with Sharia principles. It can also implement custom, if the habit is not contrary to the principles of Sharia.

Apart from the provisions of the Constitution, Article 1 of the Civil Code refers to the Sharia as the source of the first law in the case of absence of legislative provisions. Also, Article 3 of the Civil Code states that public policies are those policies that are inconsistent with basic principles of Sharia.

Furthermore, Article 27 of the Civil Code provides that in case of conflict of laws there are against Sharia law can be applied, and public policy and appropriate behavior.

Here, we have a constitutional provision that Sharia is recognized only as a source of law, while the Civil Code and the law of the Supreme Court in 1973 established the Supreme Court to consider Sharia as THE source of legislation.

Raised the level of the application of Sharia in some cases at the highest appellate court in the UAE. The court has ruled in a case, the Sharia is THE main source of law, and above all other laws. However, for legislators to apply that when enacting new legislation6, as we shall elaborate later.

These and other similar cases in the Arab countries show the suffering and conflict between the principles of Sharia and secular law. They also show how to avoid the application of Sharia courts often dubious legal reasoning, as will be explained later.

Saudi Arabia:

In Saudi Arabia, the Basic Law of 1992 has confirmed the Quran and Hadith are the sources of law and all applicable laws and regulations must comply with Sharia, which is a general law of the country. Once there is a foreign belief or contractual provisions contrary to Islamic principles will be implemented in Saudi Arabia.

Saudi Arabia follows a strict Wahabee School, developed the Hanbali school of law, even if there is a large Shiite minority in Saudi Arabia.

Civil and Commercial Code

UAE:

As stated previously, Article 1 of the UAE Civil Code states that in cases when there is no provision in the Civil Code, the judge must first rule in accordance with Shariah, which gives preference to the Maliki and Hanbali schools. And absence, the judge must apply the customary rules, if consistent with public order and morals.

Jordan:

Setting Article 2 of the Jordanian Civil Code in the absence of applicable law, the court will apply the principles of Sharia, and in the absence of Islamic rule, the court will apply the customary rules and principles of justice administered according to customary consistent with public order and morals.

It is useful to note, that the UAE Civil Code and the Jordanian Civil Code, created the first law of Sharia as a source in the absence of corresponding provisions in the law, unlike other Arab civil code in the application of Sharia refers only after and absence of the relevant laws and customary rules.

Oman:

Oman Commercial Code Article 5, 1990 with the proviso that if there is no express provision, customs shall apply, and the lack of custom, the court must apply the principles of Sharia.

Egypt and Iraq:

Article 1 of each of the Egyptian and Iraqi Civil Code contains provisions similar in the absence of legislative provisions in force, the court will adjudicate in accordance with the customs and habits, and the absence of prevailing custom and usage, the court must apply the principles of Sharia , which is most consistent with the provisions of the law. And the absence of prevailing custom or Sharia principles, general principles of justice should be applied.

Kuwait:

Article 1 of the Kuwait Civil Code of 1980 set the Sharia is applied in case of absence of an express legislative provisions and related regulations only after the loss of custom.

Thus, the Civil code and / or commercial Oman, Egypt, Iraq, Kuwait and the application of Sharia is recognized only after the loss of the applicable rules of law and custom, while the UAE and Jordan to make the Civil Code of Sharia as the first source of law.

In cases where the Civil or Commercial Code refers to the Arab countries as a source of Sharia law in the absence of relevant rules of customary law and the express provision, the question arises whether It is possible to implement a custom, if contrary to public order and morals or the principles of Sharia.

All Arab civil code states that no law or provision of the contract or custom apply if contrary to public morality and policy. As a result, it can be said that any custom contrary to the principles of Sharia Express can be considered contrary to public order and morals, and therefore will not be accepted, even when the Constitution provides a precedence of Islamic custom. However, in practice this may not happen always.

Conclusion

Forgoing analysis shows the complexity of problems and uncertainties associated with the implementation of Sharia law, particularly when important issues like the question of the validity of the legal provisions in relation to the interests involved.

However, there is a growing statement Sharia and Islamic identity in Middle Eastern societies as a result of the failure of national movements and regimes in the Arab world failed to satisfy the desire of people to achieve social welfare and to pursue an independent policy free from foreign domination. Such failures can lead to frustration and resentment, and the affirmation of the Sharia has become a way of asserting the identity of Islamic societies. Out of frustration and hatred, extremism is unfortunately increasing.

This in turn can invite Western lawyers to make themselves familiar with the principles of Sharia with the aim of finding similarities and bridges instead of just showing the differences and diversity.

In the Islamic and Arab world, still wish that an integrated law or Civil Code may one day apply to all Arab countries, only based on the principles of Sharia as a Majella, Civil Law of the Ottoman Empire, before the first World War.

After a while the last method and the extent to which the application of Sharia in some Arab countries, we have to deal with the prohibition of interest in Arabic is called "RIBA in a separate article.

No comments:

Post a Comment